The numbers, counted by Bruno
These come from Sam's own log: every join, welcome and message she processed from October 19, 2026 (the day the E2 server was born) to October 30, across the servers she serves and her DMs. It is an honest first picture, not a perfect one, and the first step of the plan below makes it exact.
1,236
unique people have posted at least once
818
posted 2 or fewer messages, ever (two thirds of posters)
715
posted once or twice, then quiet for 3+ days
470
have been quiet for 7+ days
70
posted in the last 48 hours: the living core
1,197
joiners Sam has logged and welcomed
What the log cannot see: reactions, voice time and quiet lurking are real participation too, and people who joined and never posted anywhere Sam watches do not show up as posters at all. So the true "never said a word" count needs the census in step 1.
The second post is the whole game. Almost everyone we lost, we lost between the intro and the second post.
The ideas
- Give them a reason that fits them. Not "come back," but a specific thing: a bounty that matches the skill in their intro, a Paid to Play game test, a song competition, a livestream to join. Mike's desk already matches people to bounties; churn work is that same matching, aimed at the quiet.
- Their free website is a door back. Sam built most members a site from their intro. "We freshened up your page, want to see?" is a warm, real reason to return, and it costs the member nothing.
- Show them in the story. Quiet members' work gets featured in chat and on the blog (the way Sam just welcomed a new challenger on the Points board). Being seen is the strongest invitation there is, and it never calls anyone out as inactive.
- Celebrate the near misses. Members one step from Silver, or one post from their first tip, get told exactly how close they are. A finish line you can see is easy to cross.
- Fix the front door too. New members get a day 2 and a day 4 hello from Sam with one matched micro task, so tomorrow's churn list is shorter than today's.
How Sam works the list
- Nightly census. Sam crosses the member list with each person's last message and rebuilds the buckets: Never posted, Posted once, Quiet 7 days, Quiet 14 days, Active. Bruno puts the counts on the Bear Metrics churn board.
- The queue. The welcome back list lives on Bear Metrics, every quiet member by name, with a Re-engage button. Pushing it adds that person to Sam's send list, with a draft hello written for them personally. Dave approves the script once; Sam works only from that queue.
- Public first, every time. Sam starts in the open: a showcase of their work, or a friendly tag in a relevant channel with the matched reason to return. Three to five people a day, spread out, genuinely useful.
- Then, at most, one DM. If the public hello gets no answer after a few days, Sam may send one personal DM (the script is below). One. Ever, per quiet spell. No reply means never again, and it is recorded so nobody gets chased.
- Count the returns. Every week Bruno reports how many quiet members posted again. Replies are nice; second posts are the metric. If a kind of touch stops producing them, it stops.
Sam's DM, the actual script
"Hi [name], it is Sam from E2. You joined us a little while ago and I have not seen you since your first hellos. No pressure at all, just a small hello, and one thing picked for you: post one thing you are working on in chat and I will be there to see it. Your free website from your intro is still yours whenever you want it. Hope you are well."
Short, personal, one tiny next step, easy to ignore without guilt, and it ends the conversation politely if they never answer.
The limitations, honestly
This is the part most re-engagement plans skip. Discord puts real walls around outreach, and Sam works inside them:
What Discord actually allows
- Sam can only DM people who share a server with her and have "allow direct messages from server members" turned on. A large share of people turn that off. For them, the DM simply cannot be delivered, and no setting on our side changes that.
- People who left the server, or blocked Sam, are unreachable, full stop. That is their choice working as intended.
- Discord fights spam hard. Sending many DMs quickly, especially similar text to people who have never talked with the bot, trips rate limits and anti spam systems, and mass cold DMing can get a bot flagged or banned. Our whole design (personal, different, slow) exists because of this wall.
- Public pings have limits too. One message can only mention a limited number of people, rapid tagging reads as spam to the room as well as to Discord, and @everyone is permission gated and would be wrong for this anyway.
- Never posted means never started. Members who joined and never said a word gave no conversational opening at all. DMing them cold is the riskiest and least kind option, so we simply do not. Their only route back is the public room itself.
- Attention is the deepest limit. Even a perfect, deliverable DM competes with everything else in a person's life. A small return rate is normal and expected; that is why the metric is second posts over a season, not replies this week.
Our working budget
- Public hellos: 3 to 5 people a day, spread across the day.
- DMs: start at 5 a day, never more than 10, each one personal, never a template blast.
- One DM per person per quiet spell. No reply means no second DM, recorded.
- Any block, report, or "stop" from anyone pauses that person instantly, and a pattern of them pauses the program for Dave to review.
- Nobody is ever named publicly as a churner. The list is a welcome back list, and that is how it gets treated.